Kawakawa leaf extract

Kawakawa is readily available. Chris collected the plant material for his project from various sites, including his own garden. 

Within traditional rongoā Māori, the kawakawa leaves would be collected from the part of the plant that is facing east, gets the morning sun, and has been chewed by a caterpillar as evidenced by the large number of holes present across the leaves. 

Chris chose not to follow this protocol because it would have limited the scope of his findings and he believed harvesting the leaves to this strict criteria would have been difficult. But he believes it would be interesting to conduct further research to determine whether harvesting to this criteria would in fact produce a more potent extract. 

Chris trialled seven extraction methods, based on literature and expert advice in the areas of both science and rongoā Māori. 

Chris’s knowledge of how to extract a medicinal compound from a plant was limited and it took time and practice to extract successfully. The first extractions were not successful – the resulting liquid was not homogenous in either nature or colour. 

After trialling the seven extraction methods, Chris chose two to take through to biological testing – the aqueous solution methodology and the chloroform-methanol-water (CMW) extraction method. 

The aqueous solution methodology was pursued because it was based on the technique used by practitioners of rongoā Māori. For this method, the leaves are infused in hot water.  

The chloroform-methanol-water (CMW) extraction method was chosen based on scientific literature and advice from Associate Professor David Greenwood of Auckland University. 

The two extraction methods were trialled and refined further. Then the two extracts were freeze-dried so they could be re-solubilised and added to cell cultures. 

It was important that no cell death occurred when specific concentrations of the kawakawa extract were applied to the cells because this would give false negative or false positive results. 

Three tests for cytotoxicity were carried out to prove that none of the concentrations of kawakawa extract used were cytotoxic. 

• The MTT assay showed how cell viability varied as the kawakawa extract concentration varied. 
• The Trypan Blue Cell Viability assay showed whether a particular concentration of the extract was cytotoxic. 
• The flow cytometry assay provided another measure of cell viability to confirm the results of the previous assays. 

Chris carried out the MTT Cell Viability assay and the Trypan Blue assay. 

The third assay using flow cytometry was used to ensure accuracy, but it wasn’t necessary to understand the potential cytotoxic effects of the kawakawa extract. This assay was carried out by a laboratory expert because the technique required someone with highly refined laboratory skills.   

Three inflammatory markers were measured: nitric oxide (NO), Tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF-a), and Interleukin 6 (Il-6). 

Nitric oxide is an inflammatory marker. A reduction in the concentration of NO produced by cells exposed to kawakawa extract suggests that the extract has in-vitro anti-inflammatory activity.  

TNF-α and Il-6 are two inflammatory cytokines that indicate inflammation. A reduction in the concentration of these inflammatory markers would suggest that the extract has anti-inflammatory activity. 

Chris carried out the testing for nitric oxide. He set up and observed the TNF-a and Il-6 assays, which were carried out by experts in the laboratory using flow cytometry. The TNF-a and Il-6 assays provided information that added depth and breadth to the information Chris had gained in conducting the NO assays. 

The cells were treated using a polysaccharide (LPS) known to induce the cells' inflammatory response. A control was established and then the kawakawa extract was added to the cells. 

Any reduction in the concentration of the inflammatory markers in the experimental samples – compared to the control – indicated that the extract had anti-inflammatory activity. 

The outcomes were a kawakawa extract that showed in-vitro anti-inflammatory activity and a system for testing the anti-inflammatory properties of a plant extract. 

The system Chris developed for testing the anti-inflammatory properties of plant extracts had the following attributes:  

• extraction of the plant material 
• testing of the cell viability:
  • establishes the concentration at which there is no cytotoxicity 
  • uses the MTT Assay, the Trypan Blue Assay, and flow cytometry 
  • is based on standard methodology. 
• anti-inflammatory testing:
  • uses the concentrations that are not cytotoxic 
  • tests the anti-inflammatory properties of the extract using the NO, TNF-a, and Il-6 assays 
  • is based on standard methodology. 

The aqueous extract Chris developed was fit for purpose, showing in-vitro anti-inflammatory activity. The CMW extract did not show any anti-inflammatory activity. 

Chris found that the aqueous extract could be considered for development into various products with different concentrations, such as a balm, a drink, and a beverage. Clinical trials would need to be carried out to determine the effectiveness of these products. 

Chris clearly addressed the concept of fitness for purpose in its broadest sense throughout the project. 

Fitness for purpose in its broadest sense is a concept described at level 8 of the curriculum and also within the scholarship standard, see NZQA’s Scholarship Performance Standard, Technology. 

One of the subject specific definitions for the standard states: 

Technological experiences will include: 

• undertaking technological practice to develop a technological outcome(s) that is justified as fit for purpose in the broadest sense and shows elements of elegance and/or originality. 

Fitness for purpose in its broadest sense relates to the outcome itself as well as to the practices used to develop the outcome. Beyond ensuring that the outcome itself met the requirements of the thoroughly researched and developed brief, Chris addressed this notion in the following ways. 

Sustainability 

Kawakawa leaves are a sustainable resource. Kawakawa is native to New Zealand, not under threat, and grows naturally in bush and domestic settings. 

Practices used in manufacture 

The methodology Chris used to extract the medicinal compound was fit for purpose because the aqueous solution methodology was traditionally used in rongoā. Testing the cytotoxicity of the extracts was very important for ensuring that the products were “fit for purpose” because it ensured that the results were scientifically valid.  

Cultural appropriateness of trialling techniques and ethical testing practices 

One of the reasons for conducting research into rongoā and the uses of kawakawa in rongoā was to gain an understanding of the Māori perspective towards medicine, kawakawa, and the treatment of ailments. The project was based on the traditional uses of kawakawa and it was essential to engage with rongoā in a way that was respectful. 

Chris was supported financially by Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga and they provided guidance and advice on procedures during the trialling and testing. Discussions were conducted with Professor Mike Walker, Dr Rebekah Fuller, Dr Joe Te Rito, and Dr Marilyn McPherson, as to how they personally, and Māori in general, use kawakawa and view its position in rongoā. This provided insight into how to fuse mātauranga (knowledge) Māori and science in the extraction methodology.  

The use of the aqueous solution to remove the medicinal compound was based on the processes used in rongoā. Chris spoke at length to people at Ngā Pae about their practices. 

In his report, Chris noted that neither of the previous scientific studies of kawakawa had used an aqueous extract or discussed the techniques used in rongoā. Chris’s work is a reminder of the importance of valuing traditional cultural practices and not assuming they are scientifically or technologically invalid. 

Part of the funding agreement with Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga was to provide ongoing communication and reporting about the progress and results of the project. The agreement also required that knowledge gained from the project would not be patented or commercialised because it is important that this knowledge is accessible and available to all Māori. 

Life cycle and ultimate disposal of the outcome 

The extract was stored at 4°C for a number of weeks and remained stable. When it came to disposal, the solids dissolved in water were thrown away in bags that were sent to be autoclaved (sterilised in the School of Biological Sciences facilities) and then disposed of. 

Health and safety 

Health and safety is an important part of lab work. The work was conducted in a PC-2 level lab, which means that there are established processes around the disposal of cell cultures, the treatment of waste, and ensuring that the cells were kept in a sterile environment. As a school student with very little lab experience, these were all processes that Chris needed to learn. 

Health and safety 

Health and safety is an important part of lab work. The work was conducted in a PC-2 level lab, which means that there are established processes around the disposal of cell cultures, the treatment of waste, and ensuring that the cells were kept in a sterile environment. As a school student with very little lab experience, these were all processes that Chris needed to learn. 

Consideration of the outcome's social acceptability 

Chris suggested that a rongoā user or practitioner now has scientific support for the use of kawakawa. Some of the general public have a limited understanding of rongoā and it can lack credibility. The primary technological outcome could lead to a broader acceptance of the medicinal properties of kawakawa and of rongoā Māori.  

Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga, New Zealand's Māori Centre of Research Excellence, provided advice and funding for Chris to pursue his research. The feedback from Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga showed that they were most impressed with the results of the research: 

The knowledge of the Māori peoples has contributed to new frontiers of knowledge and health. This is because the biotechnological outcomes of this project show that the traditional uses of kawakawa in rongoā are supported by scientific evidence. This technological outcome supports traditional Māori cultural practice with scientific evidence. Furthermore, the extract that demonstrated the anti-inflammatory activity (the aqueous extract) was premised on Māori knowledge. This biotechnological outcome adds new knowledge to the body of literature and so creates a new “frontier” of knowledge. 

Beatrice Copestake, HOD Technology at Howick College, believes that Chris’s natural humility allowed him to access huge support as he progressed in this project.  

Beatrice guided Chris in engineering his scientific report into the format required for a technology scholarship submission. In hindsight, Beatrice wondered if an oral submission to go with the portfolio would have provided the additional evidence to achieve an outstanding scholarship. 

As well as a scholarship in technology, Chris was awarded a Gold Crest Award for his work. His teacher, Sally Barclay, says that CREST is a great opportunity for students to extend themselves in something that they are really passionate about. 

Chris won the premier award at the Manukau Region Science Fair and attended the subsequent “Realise the Dream” event. He won the American Ambassadors Outstanding Award at this event and represented New Zealand at the International Science and Engineering Fair in California in May 2014. Chris was also top scholar at Howick College in 2013. 

Chris went on to study law and science at Auckland University. 

At the time, Chris explained his thinking about future possibilities with this work:  

“The product we made was an aqueous kawakawa extract that at specific concentrations demonstrated an in-vitro (in-cell culture) inflammatory response from a specific cell culture type. 

There are a plethora of issues in trying to translate this into an in vivo (in-body) response. A response in cells does not necessarily translate into a response in the human body. For example, it either has to be able to penetrate the skin and be absorbed or survive the stomach acid and hopefully be absorbed into the blood in the intestine. 

I think in terms of future steps, the exciting thing is that my research demonstrates that there are many opportunities in investigating kawakawa. These could include adding the extract to a balm or beverage that could be applied to the skin or proceeding down a more pharmaceutical route and trying to isolate the bioactive compound and perhaps trying to synthesise it so that it could be mass produced.” 

- Chris Ryan

This project was successful in part because of the ways in which Chris collaborated with experts, including Māori experts in rongoā. Whilst investigating the efficacy of plants for medicinal purposes is becoming increasingly popular among school students, be aware that many elements of rongoā are viewed as taonga. An awareness of the role of tikanga is important in engaging with mātauranga. In some areas there are wānanga where individuals can learn about rongoā and the tikanga that is associated with it. In some areas there are recognised experts.  

As part of wider contextual learning, students could investigate the Tohunga Suppression Act 1907 and its impacts on mātauranga Māori and the discontinuation of traditional Māori healing practices. The intellectual property associated with mātauranga Māori should also be considered, see resource suggestions below.  

Another avenue for learning could include researching and investigating the traditional medicines of other cultures, including cultures of the Pacific Nations – again with appropriate consideration of and collaboration with the knowledge holders.